Skip to main content

The Box

I used to introduce lessons in my classroom with stories, which I would then try to connect to the skill we were focusing on. Sometimes I would do a decent job, and the story would relate to what we were studying. Other days-- and this is funny-- the relationship between my story and the lesson we were learning would be so distant that it was sometimes hard to tell why I told the story in the first place. I look back on that now and laugh, but some of the things I learned were interesting. Here is just one example of a story I told my students (here, it was to introduce distinguishing fact from opinion).

There are so many stories that seem unbelievable, and yet many people will swear that they are true.

This might best be demonstrated by conspiracy theories. One of the most well-known in our country comes from an area in southern Nevada known as Area 51. On this tract of land sits a military airfield where aircraft and weapons are tested; it’s supposed to be one of the most secretive places in the world. The airspace around this field is restricted; military pilots, in fact, refer to this area around Area 51 as “The Box.”

Because it is so secretive (apparently the U.S. government “barely acknowledges” its existence), many people hold that it is a center for several activities regarding UFOs. It’s said that there is currently a UFO being stored and examined at the site, along with its occupants (meaning aliens, alive or dead); that meetings are being held with extraterrestrials; that “exotic energy weapons,” or technology aimed at controlling the weather, are being developed; that time travel technology is being created; that unusual propulsion systems (engines, for example) are being developed; and even that there are activities related to the creation of a one-world government. It’s also said that underneath Area 51 is a transcontinental railroad and that there is a disappearing airstrip that can be seen only when water is sprayed on it (called the “Cheshire Airstrip"). Here, others claim, the environment of the moon is simulated, and that Area 51 was in fact the location where the 1969 landing on the moon was faked (it is claimed that the moon landing never occurred). There’s even a person who says he was able to smuggle out a video of an interview with an alien out of Area 51. The alien in the video is in a dark interrogation room, using telepathy to communicate with scientists and military personnel.

To be an informed reader, it’s crucial that you be able to tell the difference between fact and falsehood, between something that can be proven and opinion. Knowing the difference between the two will help you understand what you should believe and what you should either ignore or investigate further. If you have this ability, it will give you a sense of confidence in your why you think something is true or false.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Nice Guy Fallacy

I read part of a poem recently by one of my favorite poets. It reads: I envy not in any moods The captive void of noble rage The linnet born within the cage That never knew the summer woods. I envy not the beast that takes His license in the field of time Unfetter'd by the sense of crime To whom a conscience never wakes. Nor what may call itself as bles't The heart that never plighted troth But stagnates in the weeds of sloth Nor any want-begotten rest. I hold it true, whate'er befall I feel it, when I sorrow most 'Tis better to have loved and lost Than never to have loved at all. At base, Tennyson contrasted a life of risk, and consequent pain, with one of security. He sides conclusively with the life of risk, and says he fails to envy those who have faced no hardship. I agree with him; and, for good or ill, his words are just as relevant today as they were in the nineteenth century. Like then, there are those today who choose to live their lives with as little risk as...

Persuasion

At different points in history, governments have devoted men, women, and resources to try to persuade others to their side. One significant example of this occurred in Germany under Adolf Hitler. Hitler knew how important it was to make sure the German people were on his side as leader of the country. One way he did this was by controlling what people heard. Specifically, near the beginning of World War II, Hitler made it a crime for anyone in Germany to listen to foreign radio broadcasts. These were called the “extraordinary radio measures.” He did this to ensure that Germans weren’t being persuaded by enemy countries to question their loyalty to Hitler. He knew that a German listening to a radio broadcast from Britain might persuade that German to believe that Great Britain was the good guy and Hitler the bad guy. This was so important, in fact, that two people in Germany were actually executed because they had either listened to or planned to listen to a foreign radio broadcast (one...

Experiment

My social studies students and I are studying Islam right now. The other day, we were reading about one of the Five Pillars, zakat (charity in Islam that means "that which purifies"). Muslims believe that giving away money helps to purify it and also "safeguards [them] against miserliness" (1). I asked the class if this was true, that giving money away makes us less greedy. They generally agreed that it does. I wanted to test whether or not they really believed this, so I handed a volunteer a $10 bill. I told the class that I would ask for the bill back the next day. I said that they should pass the bill around among their classmates, and that as a result, there would be no way for me to know who had the bill. For that reason, whoever wanted to keep the money could keep it. Even if I did learn who kept it, I told them, I would not punish that person. I wanted them to be motivated by their own honesty. The next day, I asked for the bill, and a student handed it to me...